Elliptical satellite system which emulates the characteristics of geosynchronous satellites

ABSTRACT

An elliptical satellite system which carries out communication. The satellite orbits a height above the earth less than that necessary for geosynchronous orbits. When the satellite is near the apogee portion of its orbit, its velocity approximates the rotational velocity of the earth, and during that period it appears to hover over the earth. Each ground station on the earth always communicates with a satellite within a predetermined position of its apogee, and hence that satellite appears to the ground station to hover over the earth. The satellite hence does not communicate with any earth station when it is outside of that apogee portion. During the times when the satellite is outside the apogee portion, its communication is therefore shut off to prevent any possibility of interfering with geosynchronous satellites. During this time, the power supply on the satellite is also used to charge a battery on the satellite. This enables the power supply to be made smaller by an amount equivalent to the duty cycle of the satellite: during the time which it is on.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention defines a communications system which communicatesbetween orbiting communications satellites and ground stations. Morespecifically, the system uses special communications equipment thatallows low orbit elliptically-orbiting satellites to emulate thecommunication characteristics that would be obtained from ageosynchronous satellite system. This system allows operation in a waywhich is similar to geosynchronous satellites, at a fraction of the costof geosynchronous satellites.

BACKGROUND AND SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

Geosynchronous ("geo") satellites were first proposed by Arthur C.Clarke many years ago for use with communication systems. Communicationsystems include television, two way communications, surveillanceequipment, weather monitoring equipment and other similar equipment. geosatellites operate based on the physical concept that a satellite, atthe proper working radius, orbits the earth at the same angular velocityas the earth's rotation. These satellites therefore appear to be fixedrelative to a point on the earth.

This arrangement allows an antenna on the earth to continually point atthe satellite. This facilitates use of the geosynchronous satellites forcommunications applications.

The inventors of the present invention have noted a number of drawbacksassociated with geosynchronous ("geo") satellite systems. One majordrawback is the cost to raise a satellite into a geo orbit.Geosynchronous orbit occurs at around 36,000 kilometers. The cost toboost the satellite into orbit is directly proportional to the height ofthe orbit. Therefore, it is expensive to boost a satellite intogeosynchronous orbit. This cost must be amortized over the lifetime ofthe satellite, making geo satellites very expensive.

Another problem results from the geometry of coverage of ageosynchronous satellite system. A three satellite geostationarysatellite system could have the satellites spaced equally along theequator, at 120° intervals. Their limit of visibility on the equator iscalculated from the relationship:

    2{cos.sup.-1 (R.sub.E /a.sub.geo)}=2{cos.sup.-1 (6378/35786)=2{79.73 deg}=159.47 deg,

where 6378 is the radius of the earth in kilometers, and 35786 is theradius out to the geostationary ring. Taking difference between theabove value and 120 degrees, it is clear that there is approximately 40degrees of overlapping coverage by two adjacent geo satellites for anobserver on the equator. There will be even less at greater latitudes.Many global services, however, require world-wide transmission of theirinformation to the whole world. Since each of the satellites only coversone part of the world, some other way must be used to disseminate theinformation from the source to the satellites covering the rest of theworld.

The information begins its transmission at a link. That link transmitsup to the satellite in orbit, which then retransmits the information tocommunicate to, or "cover" one portion of the earth. The sameinformation must also be transmitted to another of the satellites tocover another part of the earth. The information is either sent: 1) overa land line between the link on the earth and ground stations thatservice areas for the other satellite(s), or 2) viasatellite-to-satellite transmission. The land link requires additionalequipment and expense. The satellite link also requires additionalequipment, but in addition operates a transmission across the two endsof the 42,000 kilometer equilateral triangle. This requires atransmission which is some 70,000 kilometers long. This system requiresa second antenna on each of the satellites in addition to complicatingcontrol and pointing structure. Even then, the long communicationchannel may cause noise in the channel.

One of the most difficult-to-solve problem results from the geometry ofthe geosynchronous orbit. There is only one available orbital position("band") for geosynchronous satellites. This band is already saturatedwith satellites. Satellites occupy the geo band with only 2° of spacingtherebetween. These are referred to as orbital "slots". Most of theslots are now occupied, making it difficult to find positions for anymore geostationary satellites. However, other satellite locations cannotbe allowed to interfere with the communication to the geo satelliteswhen operating at the same frequencies.

The system of the present invention obtains the advantages ofgeosynchronous satellites without using the high altitude circular orbitnormally used for geo satellites. The present invention uses a pluralityof satellites in orbits chosen such that each desired point of coverageon the earth communicates with a different satellite at different times,and in a direction of antenna pointing separated angularly from any geosatellite(s), such that there is no radio frequency interference, evenwhen operating at the same frequency as a geo satellite. Thus, thepresent invention alleviates the present "geo-slot" problem. The loweraltitudes of the present invention also lead to smaller link distancesfrom ground-to-satellite and from satellite-to-satellite, decreasing thepower required due to path loss. These lower altitudes also decrease thetime delay which can be annoying in voice transmissions. Thus, thepresent invention provides a unique solution to some of the problems ofusing geo satellites.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

These and other aspects of the invention will be described withreference to the accompanying drawings in which:

FIG. 1 shows a basic layout of the multiple elliptical orbits of thepresent invention;

FIG. 1A shows a graphical depiction of the satellite's angular motionalong its orbit as a function of the semi-major axis of the ellipticalorbit.

FIGS. 2A-2B show a layout of the satellite communication equipment usedaccording to the present invention;

FIG. 2C shows a flowchart of operation of the satellites of the presentinvention;

FIG. 3 shows the characteristics of a basic ellipse;

FIGS. 4A-4F show characteristics of the three-satellite orbit of thepresent invention;

FIG. 4G shows characteristics of this orbit which prevent interferencewith geosynchronous satellites in an inclined orbit;

FIG. 4H shows characteristics of this orbit which prevent interferencewith geosynchronous satellites in an equatorial orbit;

FIGS. 5A-5E show characteristics of the five satellite orbit of thepresent invention;

FIG. 6 shows an overall view of the ten satellite orbit of the presentinvention;

FIGS. 7A-7G show the positions of the satellites of the ten satelliteembodiment within their repeating ground tracks; and

FIG. 8 shows the operating elevation angles for the ten satellite orbit,and their angular isolation from geo satellites.

DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT

The system of the present invention defines a communication systemincluding ground communication equipment and a special constellation ofsatellites in elliptical orbits at lower altitudes than those necessaryfor geosynchronous, which simulate the characteristics of ageosynchronous orbit from the viewpoint of the ground communicationequipment on the earth. The inventors recognized that satellites whichorbit in certain elliptical orbits spend most of their time near theapogees of their orbits: the time when they are most distant from theearth. These satellites spend only a minority of their time near theirperigee. For example, an elliptical satellite in a 12-hour orbit spendseight of those hours near its apogee. By appropriately choosingcharacteristics of the satellite orbit, the satellite can be made toorbit, during that time, at a velocity that approximates the rotationalvelocity of the earth. The present invention defines a communicationsystem using a constellation of satellites chosen and operating suchthat a desired point on the earth always tracks and communicates with asatellite at or near apogee.

Another important feature of the present invention is the recognition ofhow this mode of operation of the satellite changes its powercharacteristics. Geosynchronous satellites are used virtually 100% ofthe time (except when in eclipse) and hence their power supplies must becapable of full-time powering. This means, for example, if the satelliterequires 5 Kw to operate, then the power supply and solar cells must becapable of supplying a continuous 5 Kw of power. The satellites of thepresent invention, however, are not used 100% of the time. During theperigee portions of the satellite orbit, the satellites are typicallynot using most of their transmit and receive capability and hence, theinventors recognized, do not use a large part of their power capability.

The inventors of the present invention recognized this feature of thesatellites, and realized that the satellites could be storing the powerthat is being produced during this time of non-use. Therefore, theinventors realized that the size of the power supply could be reduced bya factor of the percentage of time that the satellite is not used.

The power sources can be any known means, including solar cells, nuclearreactors, or the like. If the satellite is used half the time, then thepower source need only be sized to provide half the power. At times whenthe satellite is not being used, the power source provides power to abattery storage cell, which holds the power in reserve for times whenthe satellite is being used.

Like geo systems, the satellite of the present invention is virtuallycontinuously in the same location. Unlike geo-based systems, however,the ground communication equipment of the present invention does notalways communicate with the same satellite. The satellites move slightlyrelative to the earth, i.e. they are not always precisely at the samepoint in their apogees. One important advantage of the present inventionis that the one satellite at apogee later moves to perigee, and stilllater to other locations overlying other continents and areas. Hence,that same satellite can later communicate with those other areas.Therefore, this system allows a store-and-dump type system. Theinformation can be stored on board the satellite and laterre-transmitted when the satellite overlies those other areas. Thissystem also allows all the satellites in the array to communicate withthe other satellites in the constellation.

This system has a number of other distinct advantages. Importantly, thesystem operation allows selecting specific geographic locations to bepreferentially covered; for example, continents can be followed by theconstellation to the exclusion of other areas, e.g. ocean areas betweenthe continents. The communication equipment on the continent alwayscommunicates with one satellite at apogee, although not always the samesatellite. From the point of view of the ground station, the satelliteappears to hover over the ground.

This satellite system operates virtually like a geosynchronous satellitesystem. Importantly, these satellites according to the present inventionorbit at about half the altitude of the geo systems. A geo orbit orbitsat 36,000 miles altitude: the virtual geo satellite orbits at averagealtitudes of 16-18,000 miles. Also, geo satellites require "apogeemotors", to boost them from their original orbits into the final geoorbit. These apogee motors can double the weight of the satellite.

This yields a communications system which costs less dollars per launchcapability because of the reduced weight to boost and less size. Also,since the geo satellites orbit at a higher altitude, they operate at ahigher power, and use a larger illuminating antenna, all otherconditions on the ground being equal. These satellites also have a muchlarger overall size. This size of the satellites increases as the squareof the distance. Therefore, the geo satellite needs to be at least twiceas large and twice as powerful as a low altitude satellite. The powersupply conservation techniques of the present invention allow thesatellite to be made even smaller.

The system also provides satellites with very high elevation angles.Maximizing the elevation angle prevents interference with existingsatellites such as true geosynchronous satellites.

This is another feature of the present invention which allows thesesatellites to operate in ways which avoid any possibility ofinterference with the geo band.

Another objective and important feature of the present invention is itsability to re-use satellite communication channels. Regulatory agenciessuch as the FCC allocate frequency bands by allocating a specificfrequency band for a specific purpose. The geo satellites, for example,receive an assignment of a frequency band. Thereafter, the regulatoryagency will consider that other satellites located in the same orbitalposition can not use this frequency because of possibility ofinterference. Hence, frequencies in adjacent bands which might interferewith that assigned band will not be allocated for new satellite use.With the present invention, there is a large angular separation betweenthe geo-sats and those covered by the invention. Thus, the samefrequencies ca be allocated anew. Another feature of the presentinvention is the location of the earth stations and satellites in a waywhich prevents interference with the geo bands. Specifically, thepresent invention defines embodiments using both inclined orbits andnon-inclined (equatorial) orbits. The inclined orbit embodiment of thepresent invention only communicates with the ground stations when a linedrawn between the ground station and current position of the satellitewill not intersect any point within x° of the ring of geosynchronoussatellites, where x is the required separation between the communicationfor geo satellites and the communication for the satellites of thepresent invention. During other times, the equatorial component of thecommunication is shut off. The satellite only communicates when it isnear apogee. During those times, the rotational velocity of thesatellite approximates the rotational velocity of the earth, and hencethe satellite tends to hang overhead relative to the earth.

For non-inclined (equatorial) orbits, the ground stations are placed ina position such that the communication does not intersect the ring ofequatorial orbits.

The system is controlled by on-board processor 280, which determines theposition in the orbit and the steering of the antenna from variousparameters. Processor 280 carries out the flowchart shown in FIG. 2awhich will be described herein.

The overall system is powered by power supply 290 which supplies powerto all of the various components and circuitry which require such power.Power supply 290 includes a source of power, here shown as a solar array292, and an energy storage element here shown as a battery array 294.Importantly, according to the present invention, the solar array 292 issized to provide only some amount of power less than that required topower the satellite communication. The amount by which the solar arraycan be less is called herein the power ratio of the device. The powerratio depends on the kind of orbit that the satellite will have, and howlong the satellite will be transmitting during each elliptical orbit.The preferred power ratio is 0.5: this will power a satellite which iscommunicating half the time, and the other half the transmitter andreceiver on board the satellite is off and the solar array is providingpower to charge battery 294.

The flowchart of operation is shown in FIG. 2a. Step 350 representscontrolling the antenna. This requires that the processor keep track ofthe satellite's position in the orbit. Step 352 determines if thesatellite is in a position in its orbit where it is active (transmittingand/or receiving). If so, flow passes to step 354 where power is drawnfrom power supply and the battery. If the satellite is not powered, thenpower is used to charge the battery at step 356.

The system also allows selective expansion of the communicationscoverage by adding additional satellites into additional ellipticalorbits.

The virtual geo satellite system of the present invention also enablescomplete communications coverage of the earth without requiring a groundnetwork. The same satellite services all different portions of the earthat different times of day. The coverage of the earth repeats over a 24hour period. A preferred embodiment receives information relayed fromthe ground, relays it to the earth area below it, then stores theinformation, and later reads back the stored information to re-transmitthat same information to other areas of the earth. The system of thepresent invention increases the satellite coverage at high densitygeographic locations using fewer satellites than was possible withprevious constellations by fixing the satellite apogee passages overgiven geographic regions defined by both longitude and latitude.

Integral values for mean motion of the satellites in the array ensuresthat the ground track repeats on a daily basis. The ground trackspreferably repeat each day so that the orbit apogee passes in the samelocation relative to the geographic target area. This system maximizesthe time of coverage and elevation angles for that pass.

Before describing the minimum satellite arrangement according to thepresent invention, the nomenclature used herein to describe thecharacteristics of satellite orbits will be first described. The "meanmotion" is a value indicating the number of complete revolutions per daythat a satellite makes. If this number is an integer, then the number ofrevolutions each day is uniform. This means that the ground tracks ofthe satellites repeat each day: each ground track for each day overridesprevious tracks from the preceding day.

Mean motion (n) is conventionally defined as the hours in a day (24)divided by the hours that it takes a satellite to complete a singleorbit. For example, a satellite that completes an orbit every threehours ("a 3-hour satellite") has a mean motion of 8.

The "elevation angle" δ is the angle from the observer's horizon up tothe satellite. A satellite on the horizon would have 0° elevation whilea satellite directly overhead would have 90° elevation. Geo satellitesorbit near the equator, and usually have a 20°-30° elevation angle frompoints in the United States.

The "inclination" I is the angle between the orbital plane of thesatellite and the equatorial plane. Prograde orbit satellites orbit inthe same orbital sense (clockwise or counter-clockwise) as the earth.For prograde orbits, inclination lies between 0° and 90°. Satellites inretrograde orbits rotate in the opposite orbital sense relative to theearth, so for retrograde orbits the inclination lies between 90° and180°.

The "critical inclination" for an elliptical orbit is the planarinclination that results in zero apsidal rotation rate. This results ina stable elliptical orbit whose apogee always stays at the same latitudein the same hemisphere. Two inclination values satisfy this condition:63.435° for prograde orbits or its supplement 116.565° for retrogradeorbits.

The "ascending node" is the point on the equator where the satellitepasses from the southern hemisphere into the northern hemisphere. Theright ascension of the ascending node ("RAAN") is the angle measuredeastward in the plane of the equator from a fixed inertial axis in space(the vernal equinox) to the ascending node.

The "argument of perigee" is a value that indicates the position whereorbital perigee occurs. When using equatorial orbits, 0° argument ofperigee is used for all the orbits. Inclined orbit arrays use non-zeroarguments of perigee. Arguments of perigee between 0° and 180° locatethe position of perigee in the northern hemisphere and hence concentratethe coverage in the southern hemisphere. Conversely, arguments ofperigee between 180° and 360° locate the perigees to the southernhemisphere and hence concentrate the coverage on the northernhemisphere.

The preferred embodiment of the present invention evenly spaces the axesof the ellipses. The spacing between RAANs is called "S" and calculatedby S=360/n=120°.

The present invention positions the satellite coverage based on bothlongitude and latitude of the desired continental area to be covered bythe orbit. This is done, first, by synchronizing the orbit apogee topass over the targeted geographical region for each successivesatellite. We select a suitable value for the mean anomaly, which is afictitious angle relating to the elapsed time in orbit. 360° representsthe completion of the orbit. In this example, the mean anomalies arealso S=120° apart.

This "mean anomaly" M relates the amount of time it takes the satelliteto rotate S° around the earth (here 1200). The mean anomaly required forthe 12-hour satellites to rotate to S° is 8 hours; two-thirds of aperiod. This corresponds roughly to the amount of time the satelliteremains in apogee.

Taking the initial satellite near apogee, therefore, (180° mean anomaly)the next satellite should be backed up by 240°. This means that after 8hours that satellite will be at 180°. Since 180° minus 240° is negative60° which equals 300°, this is the value of mean anomaly M for satellitenumber 2. This system is used to select values for the constellation ina similar manner for each succeeding satellite.

Arrays with more satellites ("higher order arrays") can also be madeusing the same rules as those discussed above. Successively largernumbers of satellites can be used to provide more coverage, moreoverlapping coverage, or smaller integral mean motion values. As thevalues of M get larger, the eccentricity of the ellipses become smaller.This is because the perigee altitude is fixed at about 500 km to avoidre-entry and decay into the earth's atmosphere; longer periods havehigher apogee altitudes greater supportable eccentricities.

FIG. 1A shows how the satellite ellipse is selected to have an angularrate in the plane of the equator, at apogee, which approximates theangular rate of the earth. The dotted line in FIG. 1A represents theangular rate of a geo satellite, and hence at this angular rate asatellite would approximate the angular speed of the earth. The ellipseis selected to have a semi-major axis length to set the minimum angularrate of the satellite at apogee. At apogee, the satellite angular rateshould approximate the rotational velocity of the earth. In reality,this rotational velocity will be either a little faster or a littleslower than the earth. At this time, therefore, the satellite appears tohang relative to the earth.

All elliptical orbits, including those described herein, are alsosubject to effects of long-term perturbations. If effects of these longterm perturbations are not compensated, this could cause continentalcoverage to drift with the passage of time.

These perturbation effects are mainly effects from the Earth's J2rotation harmonic. The earth is not a perfect sphere; it actually bulgesat the equator. This causes gravitational effects on objects which orbitthe earth. For posigrade orbits (i>90°) the line of nodes will regress.For inclinations greater than critical (63.4°>i>116.6), the line betweenthe perigee and apogee (line of apsides) will regress; for otherinclinations, I<63.4° or I>116.6, the line of apsides will progress.Exactly at the critical angles I=63.4 or I=116.6, the line of apsideswill remain stable a very desirable feature in maintaining apogee at acertain latitude. In the equatorial plane, the combined effect of thesetwo major perturbations cause the apogee to advance or movecounterclockwise from the sense of looking down from the celestial northpole. All of the satellites in a given array design would be affectedsimilarly. Fortunately, this effect could be compensated by slightlyincreasing the period of each satellite in the array by an amount whichoffsets the J2 perturbation. This affects the system by causing a pointon the earth to take a slightly longer time to reach the satellite'snext apogee arrival point. This effect is compensated by slightlyincreasing the satellite's period. The advance of perigee is suppressedby setting the inclination at one of the critical values.

A first embodiment of the invention uses N=3 satellites, where N is thetotal number of satellites, preferably in the equatorial plane, to coverN-1=2 continents. The rules for spacing and phasing the satellites willbe given in the general form that can be used later for more complicatedconstellations or arrays.

The mean motion integer sets the minimum number of satellites in thearray and n_(c) the number of continents that are followed. Here n_(c)=2 provides a satellite period equal to 12 sidereal hours. N (theminimum number of elliptic satellites in the array) is determined byusing the relationship N=n_(c) +1. Thus, N=3. This is the minimum numberof satellites that need to be in the array; we can also set the numberof satellites in the array N to be any integer greater than n+1.

The apogee passage is synchronized over the targeted geographicalregion, for each successive satellite, moving counterclockwise as viewedfrom the celestial North Pole. This is accomplished by selecting asuitable value for the mean anomaly.

Refinements: Additional features augmenting the usefulness of the abovesimpler version include:

1) Inclining the elliptical orbital planes at the critical inclinationangles (63.435 or 116.535°), with phasing to maintain a single repeatingground track. The single repeating ground track for the simplifiednon-inclined example above is simply the line of the equator. 2) Takingadvantage of the higher apogees in allowing more direct cross-linkingbetween satellites than with present low-altitude circular arrays.Usually, a single cross-link suffices, even when the longitudedifference between end points is 180° (on the opposite side of theearth). 3) Placement of apogees over a selected latitude and longitudefor optimal coverage of a potential market area. This is done throughproper selection of all the orbital parameters, with particularattention given to selection of argument of perigee, ω.

First Embodiment

The orbits of the present invention are shown in FIG. 1. The satellite100 is shown in an elliptical orbit 102 around the earth. Thecommunication equipment on the satellite 100 communicates with earthground station 104, and also beams the information to earth groundstation 106. Satellite 110 is shown in a separate independent ellipticalorbit communicating with ground stations 112 and 114 on the earth. Notealso that the satellite 100 can communicate directly to the satellite110 via communication link 120.

The preferred characteristics of these orbits are described in Table I.

                  TABLE I                                                         ______________________________________                                        Satellite No. P1        P2         P3                                         ______________________________________                                        Semi-Major Axis, a =                                                                        26553.98 km                                                                             26553.98 km                                                                              26553.98 km                                Inclination, I =                                                                             0 deg     0 deg      0 deg                                     Arg. Perigee, w =                                                                           270 deg   270 deg    270 deg                                    Eccentricity, e =                                                                           0.51      0.51       0.51                                       Rt. Ascension, RAAN =                                                                        0 deg    120 deg    240 deg                                    Mean Anomaly, MA =                                                                          180 deg   300 deg     60 deg                                    ______________________________________                                    

Satellite 100 also includes store and dump hardware thereon as describedherein. This allows the satellite to obtain program information so thatlater in its orbit, when at the position 130, it can send its sameinformation to ground station 132.

A detailed block diagram of the electronics in the satellite is shown inFIG. 2. This block diagram shows elements which carry out communicationbetween the ground station 104, the satellite 100, and the remote userstation 106. The inter-satellite links 120 are shown from the satellite100 to the satellite 110.

The video input to be distributed is received as video input 200, andinput to a video coder 202 which produces digital coded videoinformation. This digital coded video is multiplexed with a number ofother channels of video information by video multiplexer 204. Theresultant multiplexed video 206 is modulated and appropriately coded byelement 208 and then up-converted by transmitter element 210. Theup-converted signal is transmitted in the Ku band, at around 14 GHz, byantenna 212. Antenna 212 is pointed at the satellite 100 and received bythe satellite's receive phased array antenna 214. Antenna 212 iscontrolled by pointing servos 213.

The received signal is detected by receiver 216, from which it is inputto multiplexer 218. Multiplexer 218 also receives information from theinter-satellite transponders 240.

The output of multiplexer 218 feeds the direct transponders 250, whichthrough a power amplifier 252 and multiplexer 254 feeds beam former 256.Beam former 256 drives a transmit, steerable phased-array antenna 260which transmits a signal in a current geo frequency band to antenna 262in the remote user terminal 106. This signal preferably uses the samefrequency that is used by current geo satellites. The phased arrayantenna is steered by an on-board computer which follows a pre-set andrepeating path, or from the ground. This information is received byreceiver 264, demodulated at 266, and decoded at 268 to produce thevideo output 270.

The satellite includes another input to the multiplexer from thesteerable antenna, via the intersatellite link 120 and receiver 240.Transmit information for the the intersatellite link is multiplexed at242 and amplified at 246 prior to being multiplexed.

Output 222 of input multiplexer represents a storage output. Thesatellite electronics include the capability to store one hour of TVprogram information. The TV channels typically produce information atthe rate of 6 megabytes per second. The channels are typically digitallymultiplexed to produce information on 4-6 channels at a time. Therefore,the present invention preferably uses 22 gigabytes of storage to storeover 1 hour of information at about 4.7 megabytes per second. Theinformation stored will be broadcast over the next continent.

The storage unit 224, accordingly, is a wide SCSI-2 device capable ofreceiving 4.7 megabytes per second and storing 22 GB.

Upon appropriate satellite command, the output of the storage unit ismodulated and up-converted at 226.

This basic system shown in FIG. 2 can be used in one of the preferredsatellite arrays of the present invention. These arrays will bediscussed herein with reference to the accompanying drawings which showthe characteristics of these satellite arrays.

This first embodiment uses a simplified 12-hour equatorial planesatellite array n=2, N=3. The mean motion n of 2 means that eachsatellite completes an orbit around the earth twice per day.

An important enhancement of an N=3 case is obtained by modifying thecharacteristics of the orbits so that the satellites coalesce over thecovered areas at the moments when satellite coverage changes. The termcoalesce as used herein means that as one satellite moves out of rangeof the ground tracking, the next satellite moves into range at that sameposition. In fact, the two satellites come very close to one another atthat point--within 1° from the view of the satellite. This simplifiesthe ground tracking, since the switchover between satellites does notrequire much antenna movement.

FIGS. 4A-4F show the basic three-satellite "rosette" formed by the threeelliptical orbits. The earth 300 is located at one of the foci of eachof the three ellipses of the respective satellites. Satellite 302communicates with point 304 on the earth. Satellite 302 orbits the earthin ellipse 306. The satellites 1, 2 and 3 respectively have ascendingnodes of 0, 120 and 240, and respectively have mean anomalies of 180,300, and 60.

Similarly, satellite 310 orbits the earth in ellipse 312, and satellite320 orbits the earth in ellipse 322. Satellites 310 and 320 are both ina position to provide coverage to the second covered continent area 314.Note that satellites 310 and 320 are in their coalesced position --theyare very close positionally, to one another. Satellite 320 is movingaway from apogee while satellite 310 is moving toward apogee. Thetracking antenna is hence commanded to switch between tracked satellitesat the time when satellites 310 and 320 are positionally very close buthaving adequate angular separation to avoid self-interference. Accordingto the present invention, this switchover occurs when the satellites arewithin 5° of each other.

The satellites all orbit in a counter-clockwise direction relative tothe sense shown in FIG. 4. The earth also orbits in thecounter-clockwise direction. The semi-major axes of the ellipses in FIG.4 are shown as axes 308, 314, and 316, respectively.

In order to describe these orbits, first the characteristics of anellipse will be described. FIG. 3 shows ellipse 400, having a focus 402.The satellite orbits along the path of the ellipse 400, with the centerof the earth being at the focus position 402 ("the occupied focus").

The apogee 404 and the perigee 406 of the orbits are defined by thepoints on the ellipse which are farthest from and closest to the focusof the ellipse, respectively. The amount of difference between thesedistances define the eccentricity of the ellipse. The semi-major axis408 is defined as half of the long axis of the ellipse. This semi-majoraxis runs through the two foci of the ellipse, to split the ellipse intotwo halves. The two lengths along the semi-major axis, from one edge ofthe ellipse to the occupied focus of the ellipse are called the "radiusof perigee" and the "radius of apogee"; the latter being the longer.

As the eccentricity of an ellipse approaches zero, the ellipse becomesless elliptical, eventually approaching a circle (e=0) when theeccentricity is zero. The semi-major axis of a circle is the radius ofthe circle.

The characteristics of the ellipse/ object in elliptical orbit arecalculated as follows.

    The apogee, r.sub.a =a·(1+ECC).

    Perigee r.sub.p =a·(1-ECC).

A more eccentric ellipse (higher value of eccentricity ECC) has agreater difference between the values P and R. Hence, such an ellipse isless like a circle. The characteristics of the ellipse are thereforedetermined as a function of its eccentricity.

The position of a satellite in orbit follows Kepler's laws of motionwhich states that the orbiting element will sweep out equal areas of theorbit in equal times. This results in the satellite moving very rapidlywhen it is at an approaching perigee, but very slowly when it reachesapogee. For a twelve hour elliptical orbit, therefore, it can be seenthat the satellite will spend most of its time near apogee. The numberson the ellipse of FIG. 3 represent time indications of hours passed in a12 hour orbit, e.g., they indicate the number of hours since zero thathave elapsed in a 12 hour orbit.

The preferred ellipse for the 3-satellite elliptical orbit has aneccentricity of about 0.51. This value best allows the satellites tocoalesce.

The earth rotates once in every 24 hour period, and hence takes eighthours to rotate between the major axes of the three equally spacedellipses (120° spacing). FIG. 4A shows the point to be covered 304 isinitially pointing directly towards satellite 302 which is at apogee attime 0:00. As time passes, both the satellite 302 and the earth willrotate.

As time passes, the satellites move from the position shown in FIG. 4A.FIG. 4B shows the position one hour later at time 1:00. Satellite P1 hasmoved away from apogee, although it has moved relatively little.Satellite P2, on the other hand, is now moving much more rapidly at thistime, since it is approaching perigee, while P3 is still near the apogeeposition.

An observer on or near the equator sees the nearest satellite appear toclimb in altitude from almost directly overhead, towards apogee, all thewhile staying almost directly overhead at an elevation angle of 80°-90°.The satellite is actually rotating more slowly than the earth duringthis time: it is appearing to move from east to west, rather than westto east as most low or medium altitude satellites move in the sky.

FIG. 4C shows a view of the satellites one hour later at time 2:00. Thetracked locations 304 and 314 each still view a satellite near itsapogee position. Satellite P3 continues to move towards apogee and henceappears to hang overhead. P1 is still around apogee and thus alsoappears to hover.

FIG. 4D shows yet another hour later at time 3:00. P3 is still atapogee, but P1 is approaching perigee. Notice that P2 is coming out ofperigee and approaching the coalescence point at which P1 and P3 willcross paths. That crossing of paths is shown in FIG. 4E, time 4:00, whenP1 and P2 have coalesced in their positions at the time when point 304switches over between coverage by satellite P1 and P2. At that time, thesatellites are within 1° of one another as viewed from the ground.

The above has described the satellite P1 moving from directly overheadthe point to be covered, to the point where satellite P1 no longercovers the point to be covered. Therefore, the satellite is transmittingfor eight of the twelve hours of its orbit; 2/3 of the time.

This cycle repeats. As the satellites continue to orbit, differentsatellites take similar positions to those shown in FIGS. 4A-4E. FIG. 4Fshows the cycle starting to repeat with satellite P2 moving towardapogee, satellite P1 moving toward perigee, and P3 hovering relative tothe earth near its apogee.

FIGS. 4A-4F demonstrate the important features recognized by theinventors of the present invention, whereby the satellites spend most oftheir time at apogee. At the highest points of apogee, the velocity ofthe satellite very nearly matches that of the earth, and so thesatellite appears to hang overhead. The satellite is preferably trackedwhile its angular velocity differs from the earth's angular velocity by20% or less.

Importantly, the covered areas on the earth always see either asatellite directly overhead or two satellites which are very nearlydirectly overhead. FIGS. 4A-4F show how this system actually appears tothe communications point 304 to be virtually geosynchronous. Thecommunications point communicates with different satellites at differenttimes in the satellite orbit. The communications point is alwayscommunicating with one satellite.

The satellites follow repeating ground tracks, since the cycle ofsatellite movement shown in FIGS. 4A-4F continually repeats.Importantly, this allows the ground tracking antenna 212 to continuallyfollow the same path, starting at a beginning point, tracking thesatellite, and ending at the coalesce point. After the satellitescoalesce as shown in FIG. 4A, the antenna begins its tracking cycle.

The inventors of the present invention have optimized this system forpreventing interference with geo satellites.

Specifically, consider FIG. 4G which shows a multiplicity of satellitesin inclined elliptical orbits. The present invention preferably operatesto monitor satellites at and near their apogee positions. The satellitesnear perigee are moving too rapidly, and hence are not tracked. Moregenerally, the system of the present invention operates such that thesatellites are only being used at certain times during their orbits. Inthis preferred embodiment, those certain times are when the satellitesare at apogee. Non geosynchronous circular arrays are commonly used atpresent; they are actually much less efficient, since with zeroeccentricity they spend a significantly greater time on the side of theearth away from the populated continents. The arrays of the presentinvention, on the other hand, spend most of the time at or near apogeeover the populated continents of interest, and a relatively small time(at high angular velocities) passing through perigee in regions of nocommercial interest.

The satellites are only used when their geometry is such that there isno possibility of the line of sight between the ground station and thesatellite interfering with the geosynchronous band of satellites. Thisallows the satellite communication to take place on the samecommunication frequency band normally assigned to geosynchronoussatellites.

Moreover, the present invention teaches that when the satellites are notcommunicating, either because the satellites are no longer at theirtracked apogee portion and/or when the satellites are in a region wherethey might interfere with geosynchronous satellites, the maintransmission is turned off. During this time, the power supply is usedto charge the battery. This means that the power supply can be madesmaller by some factor related to the duty cycle of the satellite.

Another consideration is since the satellites only communicate whilenear apogee, they are never eclipsed by the earth. The satellites canalways receive sunlight for solar operation while transmitting andreceiving.

For example, FIG. 4G shows satellites in orbit. In the example given inFIG. 4G, the satellites are only tracked when they are in the positionof the orbit above the line 450. The only possibility of interferencewith geo satellites comes when the tracking beam is within 10° to 30° ofthe geo band. So long as an angular separation greater than this amountis maintained, there can be no interference. Therefore, the presentinvention allows reusing the frequency bands which are usually assignedto geosynchronous satellites in a position where interference with theexisting satellites can not occur.

The same rules are used to construct higher order arrays withsuccessively larger integer mean motions and hence shorter periods.These arrays require a larger number of satellites, but provide somewhatbetter coverage of the earth.

Since more satellites are used in these higher order arrays, eachsatellite need spend a lesser amount of its time at apogee. This allowsorbits to be formed wherein the values of eccentricity are allowed tobecome smaller as the mean motion increases. The ultimate limit isatmospheric drag, which limits perigee altitudes to about 500kilometers. This would correspond to a 1500 kilometer apogee ellipticalorbit with a resulting eccentricity of (r_(a) -r_(p))/(r_(a) +r_(p))which is approximately 0.067. This described orbit is not practicalsince its period is about 1 hour and 45 minutes which is not an integralvalue for the mean motion. The next nearest value for mean motion wouldbe n=14. The n=14 orbit, however, would be so slightly elliptic that itwould not offer much advantage over the circular orbits.

Practically, those arrays having mean motions of 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 aremost preferred according to the present invention. The most preferredorbits according to this invention include the three-satellite orbits,the four-satellite orbits, and the five-satellite orbits. A particularlypreferred embodiment uses two arrays of five satellite orbits.

As discussed above, all of these orbits include long-term perturbationswhich would, if not compensated, cause the desired continental coverageto drift off with the passage of time. The two major perturbationeffects are due to the earth's J₂ harmonic; and include:

Regression of the line of nodes (for posigrade orbits), and

Advance of perigee.

For inclined orbits, the advance of perigee can be suppressed by settingthe inclination, i, at either 63.435 or 116.565°.

The combined effect of these two major perturbations in the equatorialplane, due to the J₂ harmonic term has the net effect of causing theapogee to advance in a counterclockwise direction looking down from thecelestial North Pole.). All the satellites in a given array design wouldbe affected alike. Fortunately, this effect can be compensated byincreasing slightly the period of each satellite in the array in a waysuch that the earth takes a slightly longer time to reach the nextsatellite's apogee arrival point. This is compensated by adding thisextra time to the satellites' periods. The exact amount will vary, andis a function of a number of variables, including the orbital periods,inclinations, and eccentricities.

For inclined elliptic orbits, there will be no rotation of perigee ineither direction. However, there will be a regression of the line ofnodes which must be compensated by a small adjustment in orbital period.This will cause the plane of the orbit to rotate clockwise in the senselooking down from the North Pole. If that happens, the satellite wouldpass over a selected meridian at a slightly earlier time each day (oreach repeat cycle), unless we adjust the period of the satellite. Inthis case, we would shorten the period of the satellite, whicheffectively `stretches` out the trajectory ground trace and causes theground track to repeat exactly over the life of the satellite.

As described above, third order effects due to tesseral terms may needto be compensated by small orbit maintenance maneuvers using minusculeamount of fuel.

The preferred four-satellite array is shown in FIGS. 5A-5E. This arrayshows four satellites used to track three continents. These satellitesorbit in elliptical orbits having an eccentricity of 0.6. FIGS. 5B and5D show the satellite coalescing which occurs according to thispreferred embodiment.

FIG. 6 shows an overall view of the 10 satellite array; and FIGS. 7Aψ7Eshow the ground tracks for a satellite array with 5 satellites having aperiod, T, equal to 6 hours. This array is preferably used with two setsof five satellites, yielding a ten-satellite, six hour constellation.

The preferred communications system uses a ten satellite system, eachhaving six hour orbits, and each optimized for users in the Washington,DC area. This still, however, provides coverage throughout the rest ofthe continental United States, and the entire northern hemisphere aswell as that part of the southern hemisphere down to about 10 deg Southlatitude.

The system uses ten equally-spaced prograde satellite orbit planes. Allsatellite orbits are at the `critical` inclination angle of 63.435° toprevent rotation of the line of apsides.

The ground track is adjusted so as to pass directly over Washington, DCby adjusting the right ascensions of all the orbits while maintainingtheir equal spacing. The argument of perigee is adjusted to obtainapogees over or nearly over the targeted latitude and longitude.

FIG. 6 shows an overview of the orbital constellation. It can readily beseen that the satellites favor the Northern Hemisphere by spending moretime, and reaching a higher altitude in the Northern Hemisphere. FIG. 6shows a snapshot of time at 0:00 hours, and it should be seen that allsatellites except for satellites P5 and P1 are over the NorthernHemisphere at that time.

FIGS. 7A-7G show a Cartesian, or Mercator, plot of the world showing therepeating ground tracks. The satellite array has a repeating groundtrack that repeats every 24 hours. The satellites appear to `hover` ordwell along four equally-spaced meridians, one of which is at thelongitude of Washington, DC; the others being spaced at 90° intervalsfrom Washington.

FIG. 8 shows the minimum elevation angle to the highest satellite overWashington, DC, as a function of time. Every 24 hour period has tenelevation angle peaks of satellites on a descending (from northproceeding towards the equator) at or near the observer's zenith (90deg). The lower, sharper peaks in the figure represent other satelliteson ascending passes; they are at lower altitudes and thus going faster.These ascending satellites are not actively transmitting to users on theground at the times when they are on ascending passes.

The preferred system uses a total of ten (10) satellites incritically-inclined (i=63.4 deg) 6-hour orbits, phased and oriented toprovide optimal earth coverage. As will be seen, this geometry alsoprovides a very high elevation angle, and hence avoids interference withthe existing geo communications satellite band. The preferred orbitshave apogee and perigee altitudes of 20074 and 654 kilometers,respectively.

From a user's viewpoint, the satellites are accessed sequentially atnominal 2 hour and 24 minute intervals at exactly the same point in thenorthwestern sky (the `start point` of the tracking segment), and aretracked in a roughly northwest to southeast trajectory to a point in thesky well short of intersecting the geo band of satellites. Thesatellites remain at apogee during the time while they are being trackedfrom the ground. Hence, these satellites are only tracked, andcommunicated with, while their velocity closely matches the velocity ofthe earth. When the satellites begin to approach the perigee stage, andhence their velocity increases relative to the earth's rotation todiffer therefrom by more than 25%, for example, they are no longer beingtracked by the communication equipment on the earth. At this end pointof the tracking segment, the ground communications antenna is directedback to tracking its start point to repeat the sequence as thenext-appearing satellite is acquired. Tracking along the active arcsegment is accomplished at less than 2 deg/min. For the present array,this results in every ground communications antenna effecting tenswitchovers per day. As explained above with reference to FIG. 1, thesteering operation of the present invention preferably uses phased arraysteering of the antenna. However, more-conventional antenna steering isalso contemplated.

Importantly, the trajectory segments appear exactly the same to the userfor every satellite, since the azimuth-elevation trace is repeated foreach satellite.

This system defines significant advantages. Its operating altitudes arehalf that of existing geo systems. This greatly reduces link margins andemitted power requirements for the satellites.

Apogees are placed on the meridians of longitude of theheavily-populated areas for which the constellation is optimized. Apogeepoints may also be adjusted to approximate the targeted area latitudesas well. The satellite tracking arcs over the targeted areas remainroughly overhead (within 30°-40° of zenith), with slow angular movementduring periods when the satellite is active. The trajectories formid-latitude (20°-50° North latitude) observers located directly underthe apogee points in the high-population targeted areas areapproximately north-south oriented.

All ten ground tracks are identical, and only the satellite that iscurrently covering the repeating ground tracks change. The repeat cycleis 24 hours. Since the satellites move from one geographic area toanother, information once transmitted can be re-broadcast at anotherlocation.

The Mercator plot of FIGS. 7A-7E show that the entire system actuallyfollows one ground track, repeating after 24 hours. It actually `foldsover` from the left edge of the world map to the right edge, giving itthe appearance of multiple traces.

Table II gives the orbital parameters, or ephemerides, of the entirearray of ten satellites:

                  TABLE II                                                        ______________________________________                                        SYSTEM ORBITAL PARAMETERS                                                     Sat                                 RAAN   MA                                 #     a (km)  i (deg)  e, (ecc.)                                                                            w, (deg)                                                                            (deg)  (deg)                              ______________________________________                                        1     16742   63.435   0.58   315    0      0                                 2     16742   63.435   0.58   315   072    072                                3     16742   63.435   0.58   315   144    144                                4     16742   63.435   0.58   315   216    216                                5     16742   63.435   0.58   315   288    288                                6     16742   63.435   0.58   315   180     0                                 7     16742   63.435   0.58   315   252    072                                8     16742   63.435   0.58   315   324    144                                9     16742   63.435   0.58   315   036    216                                10    16742   63.435   0.58   315   108    288                                ______________________________________                                    

Some adjustments will be required to account for long term orbitalperturbations as described above. This adjustment is common insatellites requiring precise repeat cycles such as Topex-Poseidon, orthe Canadian Radarsat.

Similar views to those from the above can be drawn for the preferredten-satellite array. An important point of the ten-satellite array,moreover, is that there is good inter-satellite connectivity forcross-linking.

FIG. 7A shows the position of the satellites at time 00:00. Compare thiswith FIG. 7B, which shows the same satellites twenty-four minutes later.The satellite P4, which is substantially over Washington, D.C., hasmoved very little, albeit P5 will be picking up speed as it approachesperigee. P4 appears to hang over Washington, D.C., since it is near theapogee portion of its orbit and its velocity very closely matches thevelocity of the earth.

In contrast, during the same short period of time, the satellite P1, atperigee, has moved very quickly and very far along its orbit. Similarly,satellite P8 (over Europe), P5 (over Southern Africa) and P9 have movedvery little. Twenty-four minutes later, FIG. 7C shows that satellite P4has started to move away from the United States, but satellite P7 is nowin place, very close to its apogee. This is evident from its positiontwenty-four minutes after that, shown in FIG. 7D, where satellite P7 hasmoved only very little, and is still well-covering the United States. Attime 1:36 shown in FIG. 7E, the satellite P7 is over Washington, D.C.

The satellite P7 is still over Washington D.C. at time 2:00 hours, shownin FIG. 7F. The satellite starts to move at time 2:24, shown in FIG. 7G.

The present invention intends that the satellites be used forcommunication during only some part of the time while they are in orbit.During other times in orbits, the satellites are not being used forcommunication, but instead are charging their energy storage. Thisfeature of the invention has been described above, but will be describedin more detail herein with reference to FIGS. 2A, 4G and 4H.

FIG. 4G shows a view of the earth from, for example, the view of thesatellite from the sun. This figure shows all of the satellite orbits,and their elliptical orbital paths. The geosynchronous satellites are inequatorial planes shown as the geo ring 800. Communications equipment onthe earth communicates with this geo ring 800. Moreover, sometimes thegeo satellites are perturbed by the earth's oblateness, henceeffectively forming orbits which are slightly inclined. The geo ringsshould therefore be considered at occupying a 5° position borderingtheir nominal position.

Ground communications equipment on the earth communicates with this georing. The cone of communications to the geo ring is shown as 802.

When the ground communication equipment on the earth communicates withthe satellites P1-P5, it should be seen that they are aimed at aposition of the sky, 804, which is completely separated from the georing 802. According to the present invention, a distance is maintainedbetween the satellites and the geo ring 800. The angular separation θ isthe minimum acceptable angular separation which can ensure nointerference between the geo ring and the satellites of the presentinvention. The preferred embodiment uses an angular separation of 30°,which is an amount which will obviate any possibility of interferenceproblem. More generally, however, any angular separation greater than15° would be acceptable.

Taking the satellite P3 as an example, therefore, the satellite can onlybe used according to the present invention when it is in its orbitbetween the points labelled 808 and 810. However, the virtual geo systemwhich is preferably used according to the present invention uses thesesatellites during even less of their orbit, only between the points 812and 814. When the satellite is in the other positions of its orbit, thesatellite is not consuming power or transmitting. Therefore, thisprevents any possibility of interference with the geo satellite systems.

The operation of the equatorial satellites is similar. The equatorialsatellite array is shown in FIG. 4h. The equatorial satellite is shownas satellite ring 850. If the ground station is on the equator, shown asground station 852, then it would, at least at some times, interferewith satellites in the geo ring shown as 854. However, if the groundstation is separated from the equator by at least 30°, such as shown asposition 856, then at least part of the satellite ring has no chance ofinterference with the ring 854. Therefore, the satellite calculatesgeometries such as to obviate interference with the satellite ring.

Therefore, more generally, the present invention operates as shown inFIG. 2a. The antenna is controlled at step 350, and from the antennacontrol the position of the satellite relative to geo are determined atstep 870. This can be determined, for example, from the pointing angleof the antenna. Step 872 determines if there is any possibility ofinterference between the two. This is determined from a numericaldifference between the pointing angle and the position of the geo ring.If there is any possibility of interference, control passes to step 874where the satellite communications is disabled. If interference is notpossible at step 872, then the satellite is enabled at step 874. Anenabled satellite can be, but is not necessarily, turned on. Forexample, in the virtual geo embodiments, the enabled satellite will bemaintained in the "off" position during some of the time when it isenabled. Therefore, step 352 determines if the satellite is powered.This may be determined from the repeating ground track, or otherinformation. If the satellite is not powered at step 352, the battery ischarged at step 356. If the satellite is powered, then power is drawnfrom both the supply and the battery at step 354.

Although only a few embodiments have been described in detail above,many modifications are possible in the preferred embodiment withoutdeparting from the teachings thereof.

The above has described baseline arrays with simplified orbitalelements. It should be understood that the actual array may be rotatedeast or west by any desired amount by adding or subtracting a constantangular offset to each satellite's right ascension (RAAN). Additionally,other orbital parameters such as argument of perigee (ω) may be adjustedto improve performance a different market area.

All such modifications are intended to be encompassed within thefollowing claims.

What is claimed is:
 1. A ground-to-satellite communication systemcomprising:a first ground communication system, including communicationequipment therein, located at a first position on the earth; a secondground communication system including second communications systemtherein, located at a second position on the earth spaced from the firstposition; a plurality of satellites in orbits circling the earth, eachsatellite always having an orbital height which is lower than a heightnecessary for geosynchronous orbit, and each said satellite havingcommunications equipment thereon, said communication equipmentcommunicating with said ground stations, said satellites orbiting inelliptical orbits having apogees and perigees, and having ground trackssuch that each said ground communication system is always able to trackone satellite within a predetermined angular separation from the apogeepoint of at least one of said satellites, said first groundcommunication equipment transmitting information having a volume to oneof said satellites which is near its apogee position and which receivessaid program, said one satellite including a storage memory thereon,said storage memory storing said program from said first groundcommunication equipment sent while said first satellite is near itsapogee position over said first ground communication equipment, saidfirst satellite thereafter orbiting to a position distant from saidapogee position and then terminating said transmission, and thereafterorbiting to an apogee position over said second ground communicationequipment, said first satellite communicating said program stored insaid storage memory to said second ground communication equipment; apower supply, having a capacity to produce only an amount of power lessthan said first amount of power; a power storage element, connected tosaid power supply, and operating to store power produced from said powersupply which is in excess of that used by said satellite communicationequipment; and a controller, controlling said transmitter and receiverto communicate during only a part of a total time of operation, saidpower supply and said power storage element together supplying power tosaid satellite transmitter and receiver when communicating, and saidpower supply storing power in said power storage element when saidsatellite transmitter and receiver is not communicating.
 2. A satellitecommunications system, comprising:a ground station, located at a fixedlocation on the earth, and including satellite communications equipmentand a steerable antenna; at least three orbiting satellites inelliptical orbits at orbital heights lower than that necessary forgeosynchronous, each said satellite including communication equipmenttherein which operates during only a portion of a time of said orbits,and an antenna, said communication equipment communicating via saidantenna, to said antenna in said satellite communications equipment insaid ground station, each of said at least three orbiting satellitesorbiting in orbits having parameters to form a repeating earth groundtrack, and said orbits controlled such that said ground station alwayscommunicates with one of said satellites while said one satellite iswithin a predetermined angular separation of an apogee of said orbit,each said satellite including means for determining a position ofcommunication of said one satellite relative to a position ofgeosynchronous satellites, means for determining an amount of separationbetween said position of communication and the position ofgeosynchronous satellites and means for turning off the satellitecommunications equipment when said separation becomes lower than apredetermined amount.
 3. A system as in claim 2 wherein said determiningmeans is an antenna position detecting device.
 4. A communicationssystem, comprising:a ground station including a tracking antenna andtracking electronics to steer the tracking antenna to follow a desiredtarget; at least three satellites, each in separate elliptical orbitsaround the earth at altitudes lower than that necessary forgeosynchronous orbit, and each said satellite including communicationsequipment thereon which communicates with said ground station, eachsatellite orbit such that one focus of each elliptical orbit is theposition of the earth, including:a first satellite which communicateswith said ground station at a first time when said first satellite is ata position in its orbit where an orbital angular velocity in theequatorial plane of said first satellite is within a predeterminedpercentage of a rotational velocity of the earth around its own axis, asecond satellite which communicates with said ground station at a secondtime where the orbital angular velocity in the equatorial plane of saidsecond satellite is within a predetermined percentage of a rotationalvelocity of the earth around its own axis, and a third satellite whichcommunicates with said ground station at a third time where the orbitalangular velocity in the equatorial plane of said third satellite iswithin a predetermined percentage of a rotational velocity of the eartharound its own axis.
 5. A communication system as in claim 4 whereinsaid communication with said first, second and third satellitesrespectively occurs when said satellite and said earth have a rotationalvelocity which differs by not more than 20%.